The thing that hit me the most in Esther’s section is not even one single event but the buildup of everything feeling fake and forced. the New York trip is supposed to be exciting but it just keeps making her feel more disconnected. The photo scene is what really pushes her over because everyone else has a clear idea of who they are supposed to be and she doesn’t. When they try to turn her into “the poet” with the paper rose it feels empty and staged, and she knows it. That is what triggers her the worst, realizing she can’t fit into any of the identities being handed to her and also can’t come up with one of her own, so her crying feels unavoidable at that point like it’s been building the whole time. Even earlier with Hilda and the Rosenbergs there’s already this sense that something is off and cold and inhuman, so by the time of the photo she’s already emotionally unstable.
For Jane, the red room does a lot more than just scare her. It messes with her mentally, especially with the whole ghost idea and the way she starts to panic, but it also forces her to think about injustice in a really direct way. She starts questioning why she’s treated so badly and realizes it’s not actually fair. That moment where she calls it “unjust” is important because it shows she’s not just accepting what people say about her anymore. So the red room both weakens her and strengthens her at the same time. It gives her fear and anxiety, but also awareness that becomes part of her character later. It’s not just trauma; it’s also the start of her independence in a weird way.
With Isabella, her clothing stood out to me because it shows how out of place she is in her situation. She is still dressed in this light, almost delicate outfit, even after everything she’s been through, and it makes her seem exposed instead of protected. Compared to Esther and Jane, Isabella’s situation feels more physical, as her appearance shows she wasn’t ready for it at all. Her status and wealth don’t actually help her. The moment with the ring, in my opinion, is more important than anything about her clothes because it shows she’s trying to break away from Heathcliff and what he’s done to her. Her confidence is not really there at first, but you can see it starting to form when she rejects him.
Overall, all three feel connected through this idea of being trapped in roles or expectations, but reacting differently. Esther collapses because she can’t define herself, Jane starts to build a sense of justice out of her suffering, and Isabella is in the middle of realizing her situation and trying to escape it.
Leave a Reply